{"id":5464,"date":"2019-05-11T10:37:13","date_gmt":"2019-05-11T05:07:13","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/creativityatgrassroots.wordpress.com\/?p=2973"},"modified":"2019-05-11T10:37:13","modified_gmt":"2019-05-11T05:07:13","slug":"ethical-issues-in-accessing-peoples-knowledge-and-innovations-for-developing-low-cost-health-technologies-anil-k-gupta","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/demo.honeybee.org\/?p=5464","title":{"rendered":"Ethical issues in accessing people&#8217;s knowledge and innovations for developing low cost health technologies    Anil K Gupta"},"content":{"rendered":"<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">Abstract<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">There is a widespread concern all over the world about the emerging tensions in the local, regional and global dialogues on relationship between formal and informal knowledge systems. It is realized that the basic social contract between knowledge producing communities and the knowledge valorizing corporations and professionals needs redefinition. Several professional societies have incorporated discussions on ethical issues in accessing knowledge, innovations and practices of local communities involving use of local biodiversity resources. The situation becomes even more complex when we realize that the healthcare needs of large majority of poor people still are met by their own survival strategies dependent upon use of local knowledge and resources. It is obvious that this knowledge is precious and can generate viable and productive alternatives valued by modern markets. At the same time, it is also true that if this knowledge was sufficiently robust as it stands, the local health conditions would not have been as precarious as these often are in many regions because of nutritional and other economic hardships. The linkage with formal science and technology is therefore vital.<\/p>\n<p>The paper deals with four issues: (a) what can we learn from the analysis of a country wide campaign in India on documenting more than 30000 local health traditions maintained by communities and individuals, (b) whether the health priorities and the options for addressing them require new technological and institutional paradigms, (c) how can new partnership between people, professionals, public policy makers and profit-oriented corporations be conceptualized so that not only benefits are shared fairly but also the knowledge systems grow and thrive and (d) what should be the ethical code of conduct guiding the knowledge exchange, value addition and benefit sharing for generating viable health options for knowledge rich, economically poor people.<\/p>\n<p>The paper would thus provide an overview of the global debate on this subject and also suggest how an ethnobotanist can become the watchdog of, as well as the advocates for, the interests of healers, herbalists and other traditional knowledge rich communities.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">Introduction:<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">Knowledge happens when our expectations are belied, modified and sometimes confirmed.\u00a0\u00a0 Because the asymmetry in our expectations is influenced by our access to resources, institutions, technology and cultural platforms, we get different kinds of knowledge, even when we confront similar situations.\u00a0\u00a0 In any community living close to nature, asymmetry in knowledge generation and its utilization is inevitable.\u00a0 The experts exist not just in our profession, but in every profession.\u00a0 This raises the issue about conceptualizing the functional asymmetry without which knowledge systems cannot grow or provide incentives for experimentation, innovation and dissemination of either the knowledge itself or its applications for community well being.\u00a0\u00a0 Why would a community encourage asymmetry becomes apparent when we look at the problems of survival with particular reference to health.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">Whether a child is to be born, a bone has to be repaired or a chronic ailment has to be relieved, one needs advice.\u00a0\u00a0 In one of the Shodh Yatras (walk through the villages) in a village in Karnataka, a young person felt very disturbed when we paid respect and appreciated the expertise of a particular healer who seemed to be very effective in curing the cases of snake bite.\u00a0\u00a0 This village was located in the western ghat region with very rich biodiversity.\u00a0\u00a0 This young person felt that everybody in the village knew about the herbs to be used in such cases, what was so special about the old person whom we seemed to revere so much.\u00a0\u00a0 We asked a question to all the people sitting there, as to how many people had had a case snake bite in their family in the last three months.\u00a0 Three people raised hands.\u00a0\u00a0 We asked them who did they go to, for consulting.\u00a0\u00a0 All three pointed towards the old healer whom we were honouring.\u00a0\u00a0 Everybody laughed and the answer became obvious.\u00a0 While many people in the village know, not everybody knows, how to use the specific knowledge in a specific case such that it works.\u00a0\u00a0 The specific part of a generalized knowledge is available with only a few experts.\u00a0\u00a0 Society respects such experts but does not adequately incentivise them.\u00a0\u00a0 The result is, they often remain poor.\u00a0 Therefore, despite having walked for more than 2600 kms., during every summer and winter Shodh Yatra in last eight years, we have not come across many young healers.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">This is the crisis.\u00a0\u00a0 If younger generation no more feels inspired and emboldened to learn, acquire, specialize and improvise the knowledge that has been generated by the older generation, the knowledge systems come under threat of erosion.\u00a0\u00a0 I have argued that when knowledge erodes, a plant becomes a weed.\u00a0\u00a0 How does one ensure that this knowledge system grows, becomes vibrant, encourages innovations and welcomes fusion of external, institutional and formal knowledge at its own terms?\u00a0\u00a0 The ethical dilemma arise when we have to decide the terms, mediate the exchange and generate the portfolio of incentives for the community, local experts and those who add value to local knowledge.\u00a0 Ethical dilemma also arises when we the intellectuals, document people\u2019s knowledge in good faith, publish it and become the author without even acknowledging the knowledge providers or protecting their intellectual property rights.\u00a0 The question of sharing benefits seldom arises.\u00a0 When resources are allocated for adding value to local diversity and associated knowledge, decision about which problems\/whose problems get how much priority also involves ethical dilemma.\u00a0\u00a0 The irony is that healers who help us cannot provide even the primary health care to the children, when need arises because public infrastructure and market forces are invariably very weak in the regions which are rich in biodiversity.\u00a0 Sixteen years ago, in a paper entitled, \u201cWhy regions of high biodiversity have high poverty\u201d, I asked this question as to why such regions have (a) poorest public infrastructure, (b) highest rate of drop out in the primary education and lowest level of literacy, particularly of women, (c) highest level of male emigration and consequently high proportion of households managed or headed by women, (d) low level of employment and (e) high degree of poverty.\u00a0\u00a0 Ironically, the public representatives from these regions are also not very articulate and are unable to put pressure on the policy making process.\u00a0\u00a0 It is not surprising, particularly in Indian context, almost all the insurgent groups are active in precisely these regions where social, economic and institutional disparities have widened over time.\u00a0\u00a0 The last straw on the camel\u2019s back would be, if we the ethnobotanists or socio ecologists or natural resource experts\/scholars add to the disparity and asymmetry.\u00a0 This conference has to resolve some basic principles which should guide the exchange between local communities and outsiders.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><strong>Part I <\/strong><\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><strong>\u00a0<\/strong><\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><strong>Where does the problem lie:\u00a0 A brief literature review<\/strong><\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">Yamin (1995) suggests that new theories of distributed justice are required so that the distribution of resources not only among humans but also humans and the non-humans, present and the future generation may be pursued fairly in future.\u00a0 The moral and ethical issues underlying these theories will require decision about how we relate to ourselves and the nature around us<a href=\"#_ftn1\" name=\"_ftnref1\">[1]<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">The perception of nature and its social context raises tremendous ethical difficulties.\u00a0 Not all of us use similar language to describe the same human nature interaction.\u00a0 The very term, \u2018ethnobotany\u2019 itself is a problematic in its orientation.\u00a0\u00a0 Why should knowledge of local communities be ethnic in orientation whereas the music of the similar kind in western context becomes classical.\u00a0 The contradiction between what is \u2018classical\u2019 and what is \u2018ethno\u2019 is not going to be easily resolved.\u00a0\u00a0 But it is useful, as Mary Douglas<a href=\"#_ftn2\" name=\"_ftnref2\">[2]<\/a> (1995:264) suggests (cited in Cooper, 2000:1012<a href=\"#_ftn3\" name=\"_ftnref3\">[3]<\/a>) the word, \u2018construal\u2019 vis-\u00e0-vis \u2018construction\u2019 as less problematic, perhaps more consensual.\u00a0\u00a0 Whether one should use the term, Cooper asks, \u2018forests\u2019 or \u2018wood\u2019 depends upon the ethical and moral position one takes in relating to specific part of nature.\u00a0\u00a0 Both are socially construed\/constructed terms.\u00a0 Amartya Sen (1980) in his famous paper entitled, \u201cDescription as Choice\u201d asked a similar question.\u00a0\u00a0 When does description inherently suggest prescription or prediction, he said, was a function of the underlying values.\u00a0\u00a0 Thus, the poor people after sixth five year plan in India were named, in the planning documents, as \u2018weaker section\u2019.\u00a0\u00a0 He draws attention to the fact that language in this case turned the responsibility from the external forces and actors to the poor people themselves who were supposed to be weak.\u00a0 He asks as to how could weaker section carry the heaviest burden.\u00a0\u00a0 When we use the term, \u2018disadvantaged\u2019 vis-\u00e0-vis just the \u2018poor\u2019, we highlight the dialectics in one case and mask it in another.\u00a0 Culture specific to a region provides different ways of construing nature.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">Just as I mentioned in the beginning, the moment the knowledge about a plant is lost, it becomes weed, i.e., a plant out of its place.\u00a0\u00a0 Come to think of it, can a plant ever be out of its place?\u00a0 How do we determine what its place is and who determines it?\u00a0 Imagine a library without a catalogue.\u00a0 Will we be able to locate the books?\u00a0\u00a0 Perhaps those of us who have walked through the carrels may through recollection reach the point where probability of finding a particular book is high.\u00a0\u00a0 But then, librarians are creative people.\u00a0 The cataloguing assistants can interpret the titles and the subjects ingeniously.\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0 Book may not be where we suspect it to be.\u00a0\u00a0 Catalogues, therefore, have a place.\u00a0\u00a0 They need to be developed, preserved, updated and shared.\u00a0\u00a0 Local communities have been trying to do it, but with more and more difficulty.\u00a0 The outsiders use Latin names (difficult to argue why only Latin), but a common classification scheme is necessary to pool the knowledge and make it accessible to the entire profession.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">The cultural project is just the opposite.\u00a0\u00a0 As Margret Mead had stressed that the emphasis on etic meanings vis-\u00e0-vis the emic meanings was a reflection of dominating global over local.\u00a0\u00a0 The communities create meanings which are accessed more easily by the members and are often inaccessible to outsiders.\u00a0\u00a0 Conservation, perhaps requires respect for particular.\u00a0\u00a0 The scholars, used to dealing with generalized meanings construct newer and newer projects which deny the locality of the meanings.\u00a0\u00a0 This tension is understandable and to some extent desirable.\u00a0\u00a0 The problem arises when assertion of locality and within locality, expertise is construed as contrary to the communitarian spirit.\u00a0 Attempt to reinforce the respect for individual experts is interpreted as an assault on assumed communitarian process of production of knowledge.\u00a0\u00a0 The spirit is confused with the structure.\u00a0\u00a0 The communitarian spirit does not in any case violate the need for individual expertise and location specific knowledge, language, terms and above all ethical norms.\u00a0\u00a0 Should our profession consider its duty to understand, and then expand the space, both in policies and institutions for knowledge, institutions and technologies that originate in a specific socially construed spaces and cultural contexts.\u00a0\u00a0 If we have to do that, we will have to use modern science and technology to validate and value add in this knowledge according to the local parameters so that social benefits in the form of drugs for masses raise the status of the little science.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">I will come back to the issue of building bridges between the \u2018little\u2019 and the \u2018big\u2019 science without comprising much with the rules of each system of knowledge.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">First let us understand, \u2018who gets to tell the story\u2019, (Lease, 1995 in Cooper, 2000<a href=\"#_ftn4\" name=\"_ftnref4\">[4]<\/a>) implies the power of those who describe, as Sen says often to prescribe.\u00a0 Toulmin (1982 in Cooper, 2000<a href=\"#_ftn5\" name=\"_ftnref5\">[5]<\/a>) teased out the ethical dimension of ecological (or if I may, botanical) concepts and terms.\u00a0\u00a0 Those who narrate, also select what to narrate and how.\u00a0\u00a0 Therefore, the evaluation of the local knowledge only on the basis of narration by third parties may not always do justice to the dynamics and complexity of the knowledge system.\u00a0\u00a0 Since most researchers seldom share their findings with the knowledge providers before publishing or presenting at the conferences, the ethical dimension of the discourse also deserves attention.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">Bodeker (2003<a href=\"#_ftn6\" name=\"_ftnref6\">[6]<\/a>) reviews various examples where the knowledge rights of the local communities have not been respected adequately.\u00a0\u00a0 The South African example where the San people objected to the patent by CSIR on their knowledge from which a drug was developed for anti obesity, illustrates the conflict between CBD and TRIPS.\u00a0\u00a0 Bodeker strongly endorses SRISTI\u2019s proposal for a global registry of traditional knowledge and grassroots innovations.\u00a0\u00a0 He also supports the SRISTI\u2019s arguments in support of a disclosure requirement from every patent applicant.\u00a0\u00a0 Our proposal has been that every applicant should declare that source material and\/or knowledge associated with it has been \u2018rightfully\u2019 and \u2018lawfully\u2019 acquired.\u00a0\u00a0 The \u2018rightful\u2019 refers to moral as well as ethical issues in accessing biodiversity (also see Pew Ethical Guidelines and background papers prepared for the purpose, Gupta 1994a &amp; b).\u00a0\u00a0 However, the task of making databases is fraught with risks.\u00a0\u00a0 He refers to the Ethiopian example in 80s when government required traditional healers to register themselves as practitioner.\u00a0\u00a0 Many healers, \u2018submitted inaccurate information\u2019 with the result that this database was not taken seriously (Bishaw, 1991 in Bodeker 2003<a href=\"#_ftn7\" name=\"_ftnref7\">[7]<\/a>).\u00a0 He describes an initiative on Global Information Hub on Integrated Medicine as a part of Commonwealth Working Group on Traditional and Complimentary Health Systems which will build a database of various stakeholders as well as information resource regarding the intellectual property rights in traditional medicine and associated biodiversity.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">The concept of Prior Informed Consent (PIC) articulated in CBD but never incorporated in TRIPS has created considerable tensions with regard to the ethical aspect of information exchange.\u00a0 Ragavan (2001<a href=\"#_ftn8\" name=\"_ftnref8\">[8]<\/a>) feels that the concept of \u2018free\u2019 and \u2018informed\u2019 consents have not been defined.\u00a0 CBD does not provide framework of consequences when the consent is not informed or adequate.\u00a0 She asks several other questions about the right of knowledge holders to withhold or not to disclose or keep information trade secrets.\u00a0 The legal respect for traditional knowledge has been debated in different courts.\u00a0 She provides an interesting example of a case, <em>Hodosh v. Block Drug Company (786F 2d 1136 Fed.Cir., 1986)<\/em> in which a Chinese traditional medicine example was considered unacceptable as a prior art because the court observed that a \u201cskilled person exercising reasonable diligence, would not be able to locate the prior art, given the esoteric nature of references.\u00a0 The constant dilemma of applying statutory law or common law is referred as one of the persistent problems.\u00a0 She questions whether codification of knowledge is a necessary condition for a traditional knowledge system to be recognized as legally valid system.\u00a0 Toffel (2002<a href=\"#_ftn9\" name=\"_ftnref9\">[9]<\/a>) reviews the possibility of using code of conduct in the absence of legal provisions for guiding the knowledge exchange between providers and receivers.\u00a0 He refers to the code of conduct developed by various indigenous communities as well as Association of Social Anthropologists, Society for Economic Botany, International Society for Ethnobiology, NIH, NCI, etc.\u00a0 In 1994, we had reviewed many of these guidelines and found that most did not posit any consequences for violation<a href=\"#_ftn10\" name=\"_ftnref10\">[10]<\/a>.\u00a0\u00a0 Gupta and Sinha (2001) felt that the Honey Bee philosophy has not yet permeated the discourse on ethical ways of knowledge exchange, although it was enunciated way back in 1988-89.\u00a0 Toffel\u2019s advice that ad hoc contract between indigenous groups and pharmaceutical companies seemed to be the best answer for getting compensation may be a pragmatic response but is not a long term institutional solution.\u00a0 Many others such as Posey, Dutfield and Brush have made familiar arguments questioning the concept of graduated and gradient rights in the community.\u00a0\u00a0 I define \u2018<em>graduated<\/em>\u2019 rights as those which are modified subject to the value which is added in different stages of the value chain (sometime referred as milestone based payments or rights) and the \u2018<em>gradient\u2019<\/em> rights as the asymmetrical knowledge distribution within a community and thus knowledge experts not being treated at par with those who are either only aware or sometimes not even aware of the details.\u00a0\u00a0 The knowledge and ability to practice it in specific contexts is a skill developed over a period of time with enormous effort and perseverance.\u00a0 Knowledge systems would not grow or survive without such gradients being recognized as an inalienable feature of knowledge systems.\u00a0 In professional and institutional contexts, we recognize this concept very well but hesitate in according it the same respect in informal context and community context.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">Ogumanam<a href=\"#_ftn11\" name=\"_ftnref11\">[11]<\/a> believes that the alternative world view of traditional healers is not fully captured in the western bio medical approaches.\u00a0\u00a0 He considers two systems as basically incompatible.\u00a0 However, he hopes that a global framework for protection of indigenous knowledge would emerge consistent with cultural and philosophical diversity of local health traditions.\u00a0 Norchi (2000<a href=\"#_ftn12\" name=\"_ftnref12\">[12]<\/a>) refers to the traditional Onge people of Indian Nicobar and Andaman Islands and suggests that customary laws evolved by Onges need to be recognized by forming Onge Corporation.\u00a0 The corporate firm could respect the trust of the community who could be share holders.\u00a0\u00a0 The corporation would then enter into contract for their knowledge to be accessed by outsiders.\u00a0 He refers to the work of Ashish Kothari and many others who have raised the issue of Onges. \u00a0The health leads from one of the oldest tribes of the world would obviously be of interest to the Indian society.\u00a0\u00a0 Whether utilitarian logic will suffice in this context, is the issue that we need to address.\u00a0 Posey (1990<a href=\"#_ftn13\" name=\"_ftnref13\">[13]<\/a>) had suggested a new eco-ethno ethics, essentially enforced by not the law but the professional societies.\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0 He warned that anthropologists and ethnobiologists would lose the respect of native people if they did not follow proper ethics.\u00a0 Brush (1993<a href=\"#_ftn14\" name=\"_ftnref14\">[14]<\/a>) also feels that ethnobiological information collected so far did not touch upon several issues that were arising due to commercialization prospects.\u00a0\u00a0 He believes that Intellectual property may be less attractive way than guaranteeing human, cultural or land rights in \u2018meeting the goals of conserving indigenous knowledge and providing more equitable treatment for indigenous people who have been generous with their knowledge and resources\u2019 (1993: 667).\u00a0 Obviously, he confuses the issue of intellectual property rights with the available legal arrangements for enforcing these rights.\u00a0 Former are non-negotiable and latter are subject to debate and can be improved.\u00a0\u00a0 Knowledge rights are at the root of cultural and other rights.\u00a0 Gadgil, et al (2000<a href=\"#_ftn15\" name=\"_ftnref15\">[15]<\/a>) explains the concept of People\u2019s Biodiversity Register (PBR) and suggests that these registers could be a tool for conserving and respecting folk knowledge.\u00a0\u00a0 They also suggest that compensation could follow according to the quality of documentation (which will often be done by outsiders).\u00a0 They propose that in due course this knowledge could be fed back to the people from whom it is collected.\u00a0 Recently, National Innovation Foundation (NIF) and a community in Karnataka having developed PBR signed an MOU to honour the knowledge rights of the communities, already articulated in the PIC framework used by NIF (see <a href=\"http:\/\/www.nifindia.org\/pic.htm\">www.nifindia.org\/pic.htm<\/a>).\u00a0 Simpson, Sedjo and Reid (1996<a href=\"#_ftn16\" name=\"_ftnref16\">[16]<\/a>) had earlier cautioned that despite much hype about the biodiversity use in pharmaceutical research, not much benefit may flow to the people either for conservation or for consumption because the companies had several options and the biodiversity based options were necessarily the most attractive ones.\u00a0 Lewis and Ramani (2003) feel that ICBG proposal in Peru was fair on account of communication, confidentiality and compensation.\u00a0 However, the issue of who all were the, \u2018authors\u2019 of the knowledge was controversial.\u00a0 They endorse the proposal of community rights in the national and international law.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">Cochran (2005<a href=\"#_ftn17\" name=\"_ftnref17\">[17]<\/a>) describes the ethical guidelines of the Yukon First Nation people from Alaska region.\u00a0 The Alaska Federation of Natives (AFN) requires that native people be advised about the purpose, goal, timeframe, data gathering technique, impact \u2013 positive and negative of the research; the informed consent of appropriate governing body.\u00a0 Fund the monitoring committee of the native people to track the research project and ensure the compliance, protect the sacred knowledge and cultural and intellectual property, hire and train native people in the study, use native language whenever English is the second language, ensure confidentiality, incorporate native people\u2019s view points, acknowledge local contribution, inform the community about the major findings and provide the copies for the local library.\u00a0 This, to me, is a neat summary of what the local communities aspire.\u00a0 We could benchmark our practices against this expectation and judge for ourselves as to how far have we reached.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">However, as we know, no ethnobiology or ethnobotany conference has refused to accept a paper unless it follows the concepts of (a) PIC, (b) sharing of knowledge with the knowledge providers in the manner and language they understand before sharing it with third party, (c) not treating knowledge providers anonymously, (d) ensuring that any benefits generated by the knowledge are shared with the knowledge providers in fair and just manner and (e) the rights of individual experts vis-\u00e0-vis community are differentiated as per the local norms.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><strong>Part II<\/strong><\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><strong>Healing strategies and ethical engagement with people\u2019s knowledge systems: way ahead<\/strong><\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><strong>\u00a0<\/strong><\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">Herbal formulations developed by local communities involve not just the plants, or their derivatives but also a process, a perception, and sometimes a deep philosophy.\u00a0 It is true that in most of the cases when we do documentation, we often get information about plants, their uses and in some cases the methodology.\u00a0\u00a0 There are also cases when the formulations are accompanied with some hymns or chants, essentially combining the material world with spiritual consciousness.\u00a0 The scientific evidence on the effect of prayers is not robust.\u00a0 Recent study led by Krucoff\u00a0 in July 16, 2005 issue of Lancet does not provide much support for the therapeutic effect of the prayers.\u00a0 Surely, it will not change our tendency to pray when either we or our dear ones are in pain.\u00a0 We cannot say the same thing about a herbal medicine.\u00a0 Prayer relaxes us and to that extent its effect is instantaneous.\u00a0 Herbal medicine needs to interact with our metabolic or physiological pathways and demonstrate results compatible with expectations.\u00a0\u00a0 More than 60 per cent people in India rely on herbal and alternative medicine for meeting their regular or occasional health needs.\u00a0\u00a0 Even among the 40 per cent, the popularity of herbal medicine from different traditions (ayurveda, siddha, unani, homeopathic, etc.) is increasing.\u00a0 The story of Chinese medicine is well known.\u00a0\u00a0 One in five persons in US is supposed to have used Chinese herbal medicine or food additives.\u00a0\u00a0 The knowledge about the herbal medicine abounds in most developing countries.\u00a0 In last five years, NIF scouted about 51000 grassroots green innovations and traditional knowledge practices.\u00a0 More than 70 per cent deal with herbal knowledge for curing human, animal or plant diseases\/pests or disorders.\u00a0 Formulations developed by people are often multi ingredient based.\u00a0\u00a0 Scientists find it very difficult to deal with formulations having more than 3 or 4 ingredients.\u00a0 The limits of modern science therefore define the range of opportunities one can create for local knowledge holders.\u00a0 Most ethnobotanists have documented the knowledge governed by private, community or public domain.\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0 Often the scientists will document proprietary knowledge from individuals and\/or communities and bring it in public domain without any possibility of reciprocity.\u00a0 Conferences like this have to raise fundamental question about ethics of such appropriation.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">If we follow ethical practice and people voluntarily share their knowledge with mutual faith and respect, how can this knowledge become the basis of improving societal health.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">There are five ways in which we can achieve the health objectives using herbal knowledge:<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<ol style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<li>Large number of diseases in rural areas are water borne and therefore herbal substances that can purify water of various impurities and eliminate the chances of even viral diseases should be the top priority. We must recognize the social gain of such substances for safe, affordable, accessible and widely available solution to this persistent global problem.<\/li>\n<\/ol>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<ol style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<li>In a study of about 8000 entries from our database, we found about 1000 remedies for pain and aches. Pick up any public health document and look for any reference to pains and aches.\u00a0 I doubt if we will find any.\u00a0\u00a0 I myself did not realize it till my colleagues in NIF analysed the frequency distribution of disease wise herbal leads.\u00a0 When we look at the fact that large majority of poor people and their livelihood by essentially using labour and are not able to obtain sufficient nutrition for meeting their needs, it is understandable that they would suffer from certain deficiencies.\u00a0 In addition to these deficiencies, the inability to compensate the loss of energy may also add to the burden.\u00a0 Further, the physical drudgery involved in various activities takes toll of one\u2019s stamina.\u00a0 Pains and aches are also caused by the hazardous occupations.\u00a0\u00a0 For working class, solutions to this problem which may be caused by a variety of reasons (ranging from excess fluorides to other deficiencies or sprains and other injuries).\u00a0 Various analgesics may have to be discovered to supplement the effect of aspirin which itself originated from plants.<\/li>\n<\/ol>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<ol style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<li>Nutraceuticals seem to be the next major category of solutions that can lead to healthy communities at low costs and perhaps by strengthening preventive health care. One of the problems of the working class is that it ages faster.\u00a0\u00a0 Nutraceuticals could help in extending the working life and therefore the wellbeing of the families of poor people.<\/li>\n<\/ol>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<ol style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<li>The diarrohea, diabetes, jaundice, wound, malaria and many other tropical diseases are well known candidates for discovering herbal solution. The important concern should be to distinguish four kinds of ingredients in any herbal formulation: curative, carrier, bio enhancer, suppresser of side effects or stimulator of supporting\/suppressing hormonal secretions.\u00a0 Unless we do careful analysis, we may bark the wrong tree.\u00a0 While National Cancer Institute of US screened 35000 plants and could isolate only seven leads, taxol being one of them, it does not mean that hit rate should be so low.\u00a0 One reason why scientists often fail in confirming the claims of local communities or individual healers is because of the basic difference in the protocol of extraction, delivery and dosage.\u00a0 There are many examples where healers find something effective and scientists fail to find appropriate results.\u00a0\u00a0 The heuristics of validation also will have to be taken into account while developing solutions for various diseases.<\/li>\n<\/ol>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<ol style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<li>The problems of women whose access to basic sanitation and hygiene facilities is severely restricted. Many problems occur because they don\u2019t take enough water lest they have to keep their bladder under control in situations where public toilets are often absent or available infrequently.\u00a0\u00a0 There are large number of other institutional conditions which create stress and other problems for women.\u00a0\u00a0 Millions of women have to carry water and other loads on their head and back, perform farm operations by using inappropriately designed tools, have to transplant paddy by keeping their feet under water attracting fungal infections.\u00a0\u00a0 Why should not such problems be the priority for scholars and scientists?<\/li>\n<\/ol>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">Having identified five major areas which affect working class and their children and women, how would changing the ethical discourse provide a solution?<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">Part III<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">Towards solutions:\u00a0 Learning from Gandhi<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">Gandhiji was once asked by a group of young students as to what should they do for rural development.\u00a0 Gandhiji replied that he had never worked rural areas and therefore how could he answer this question.\u00a0 The students insisted, assuming that Gandhiji was being unnecessarily modest.\u00a0\u00a0 After a while, Gandhiji relented.\u00a0 He said that while he lacks experience, he has a proposal to make.\u00a0\u00a0 Assume that we have to work in a particular problem area, say livestock development, in a given group of villages.\u00a0\u00a0 He described what he would do in such a situation. \u00a0\u00a0He will go to the villages and look for the most efficient livestock producer whose animals produce maximum milk or other products.\u00a0 He will study from morning till evening all the practices of feeding, managing, watering, sanitation, hygiene and even psychological care of the animals. He will write them down.\u00a0 Then he will study the similar practices of the average livestock producer.\u00a0 The gap between the two will be his plan of work.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">Can we follow Gandhiji\u2019s advice in using ethnobotanical knowledge for solving widespread global health problems of common people?\u00a0 Can we focus on identifying those members of the working class whose health is far superior to the rest, and study the entire set of strategies including herbal medicine that they use?\u00a0\u00a0 Likewise, we could identify local experts who specialize in solving specific problems.\u00a0\u00a0 After assuring them that the solutions will be used exactly as per their advice and with all the conditions they would impose in the PIC form, we pool the best practices and develop new products.\u00a0\u00a0 There is no reason why our hit rate will not be higher and gains to all the partners in building herbal value chain not be commensurate with their expectation.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">We should resolve in this conference a minimum protocol to be followed by all the ethnobotanists and health researchers.\u00a0 We should aim that by the next conference, the ethical barometer will show a much higher reading than is the case today.\u00a0 We should benchmark and aim that at least 50 per cent papers in the next conference will be based on this protocol.\u00a0\u00a0 The key elements of this protocol discussed many times in past are:<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<ol style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<li>Complete disclosure of the purpose of research, documentation or any other research interaction with the local communities\/researchers.<\/li>\n<li>Disclosure of the advantages and disadvantages of saying \u2018yes\u2019 or \u2018no\u2019 to different choices in local language (see annexure one on PIC note used by NIF and SRISTI).<\/li>\n<li>Clarification about two stage PIC process so that benefit sharing in general may be discussed in stage one but specific elements of agreement may be discussed in stage two when something useful has been found out.<\/li>\n<li>Clarification about the risks and chances in developing products through various stages and therefore moderating expectations, linking them with the milestone based performance indicators and assuring sharing of findings in the manner that can understand at each stage.<\/li>\n<li>Respecting the identity of knowledge providers and publishing only those results which are authorized by the knowledge providers with their name and identity.\u00a0 Unless requested otherwise, knowledge providers will always be named either as knowledge provider or as knowledge holder or innovator.<\/li>\n<li>The responsibility of taking permission of the community or informing it as the case may be, should be fulfilled without compromising.\u00a0\u00a0 It should be understood that this process can take lot of time and trouble.<\/li>\n<li>The benefits can be in monetary or non-monetary terms and can be targeted at individual or communities.\u00a0\u00a0 A portfolio of incentives will have to be evolved for different situations.\u00a0\u00a0 It cannot be same everywhere.<\/li>\n<li>The ethical basis of knowledge exchange will need to be recalibrated from time to time so that the learning at the level of community or scholars is factored in the evolving ethical framework.<\/li>\n<li>If the drug has to be patented, the patentee must take prior permission from the knowledge providers and disclose that moral and legal provisions of ethical knowledge exchange have been followed scrupulously.<\/li>\n<\/ol>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">There can be many more suggestions.\u00a0\u00a0 Protocol can be modified, tested and improved.\u00a0\u00a0 The plants which are endangered have to be conserved.\u00a0 It has to be recognized that medicines based on such plants can pose threat to the environment, particularly when such plants may also be endemic.\u00a0 The use of biotechnology or other such means to propagate such plants must be encouraged.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">Health solutions are often developed by understanding the problem of disease, disability or disorder.\u00a0 I am proposing that we study health, wisdom and wellbeing.\u00a0 Very seldom, do we ask the question why are some people are more healthy than others.\u00a0\u00a0 Let us learn from those knowledge rich, economically poor people who have solved problems through their own genius and have managed to survive sometimes sustainably and sometime precariously.\u00a0\u00a0 It is the balance between holistic and reductionist vision which will help blend informal and formal science.\u00a0\u00a0 We need both.\u00a0\u00a0 Without reductionism, we cannot specialize.\u00a0\u00a0 If a bone setter does not focus only on bone setting, he or she will never become an expert.\u00a0\u00a0 We need general physicians but we also need experts.\u00a0\u00a0 Holism is the context, the reductionism is the content.\u00a0 Without one, the other cannot sustain.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">Let me conclude by suggesting that good ethics also makes good science.\u00a0 Only when people have trust in our intentions, they will share the cases where they fail in treating a problem or cases where they had remarkable results.\u00a0\u00a0 Unless we get to learn the extreme values in the repertoire, we will not be able to dissect the problem in parts that make it comprehensible and also assimilable with modern science.\u00a0\u00a0 Let us remember that health is not absence of sickness.\u00a0 It is a moral state in which we feel responsible and because we feel responsible, we have joy, and because we have joy, we are able to build relationships full of trust and respect with people who have as much right to enjoy the same state of happiness despite all the deprivations they suffer form.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><a href=\"#_ftnref1\" name=\"_ftn1\">[1]<\/a> Farhana Yamin, Biodiversity, Ethics and International Law, <em>International Affairs<\/em> (Royal Institute of International Affairs 1944), Vol.71, No.3, Ethics, the Environment and the Changing International Order (Jul., 1995), 529-546.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><a href=\"#_ftnref2\" name=\"_ftn2\">[2]<\/a> Douglas M (1995) Acceptance of the 1994 Bernal prize. Science, Technology and Human Values 20 (2): 262 \u2013 266.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><a href=\"#_ftnref3\" name=\"_ftn3\">[3]<\/a> Nigel S Cooper, Speaking and listening to nature: ethics within ecology, Biodiversity and Conservation 9: 1009-1027, 2000.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><a href=\"#_ftnref4\" name=\"_ftn4\">[4]<\/a> Lease G (1995) Introduction: Nature under fire. In Soul ME and Lease G (eds) Reinventing Nature : Responses to Postmodern Deconstrution, pp 3 \u2013 16, Island Press, Washington DC<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><a href=\"#_ftnref5\" name=\"_ftn5\">[5]<\/a> Toulmin S (1982) The Return to Cosmology: Postmodern Science and the Theology of Nature, University of California Press, Berkeley<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><a href=\"#_ftnref6\" name=\"_ftn6\">[6]<\/a> Bodeker,G., 2003, Traditional Medical Knowledge, Intellectual Property Rights &amp; Benefit Sharing, Cardozo J. of Intl. &amp; Comp. Law [Vol.11:785-814]<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><a href=\"#_ftnref7\" name=\"_ftn7\">[7]<\/a> Makonnen Bisha, <em>Promoting Traditional Medicine in Ethiopia: A Brief Historical Review of Government Policy, <\/em>33 Social Science &amp; Medicine 193, 193-200 (1991)<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><a href=\"#_ftnref8\" name=\"_ftn8\">[8]<\/a> Ragavan, Srividhya, 2001, Minn.Intell.Prop.Rev.2(1), available at http:\/\/mipr.umn.edu\/archive\/v2n2\/raghavan.pdf<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><a href=\"#_ftnref9\" name=\"_ftn9\">[9]<\/a> Toffel, Michael W., 2002, Intellectual property rights and traditional resources: Indigenous challenge, downloaded on August 18, 2005 from http:\/\/faculty.haas.berkeley.edu\/toffel\/papers\/indigenous_manuscript.pdf<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><a href=\"#_ftnref10\" name=\"_ftn10\">[10]<\/a> Gupta, Anil K., Dilemma in Conservation of Biodiversity:\u00a0 Ethical, Equity and Moral Issues \u2014 a review, Prepared for a workshop of Pew Conservation Scholars on Developing Ethical Guidelines for Accessing Biodiversity,\u00a0 Arizona, October, 1994, published under the title, \u201cEthical Dilemmas in Conservation of Biodiversity:\u00a0 Towards Developing Globally Acceptable Ethical Guidelines\u201d in Eubios Journal of Asian and Interna\u00adtional Bioethics 5 (Japan), March 1995, pp.40-4<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">Suggested Ethical Guidelines for Accessing and Exploring Biodiversity &#8211; A Pew Conservation Scholars Initiative, October 21, 1994 (A collective effort of Pew Conservation Scholars based on three background notes including G 16 and G 17), published in Eubios Journal of Asian and International Bioethics 5 (Japan), March 1995, pp.38-40.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">Gupta, Anil K., and Riya Sinha, 2001, Should we save, what serves only human ends? A review on Environmental Ethics, published under the title, \u2018Environmental Conservation: Ethical Concerns\u2019 in International Encyclopedia of the Social &amp; Behavioral Sciences, Elsevier Science Ltd., p. 4602 \u2013 4607.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><a href=\"#_ftnref11\" name=\"_ftn11\">[11]<\/a> <a href=\"http:\/\/www.findarticles.com\/p\/search?tb=art&amp;qt=%22Oguamanam%2C+Chidi%22\">Oguamanam, Chidi<\/a>, 2004, Localizing intellectual property in the globalization epoch: the integration of indigenous knowledge,<strong> <a href=\"http:\/\/www.findarticles.com\/p\/articles\/mi_hb3300\">Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies<\/a><\/strong>, \u00a0 June 2004 &#8211; http:\/\/www.findarticles.com\/p\/articles\/mi_hb3300\/is_200406\/ai_n13064680<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\">\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><a href=\"#_ftnref12\" name=\"_ftn12\">[12]<\/a> Norchi, Charles H, 2000, Indigenous knowledge as intellectual property, Policy Sciences, 33: 387-398.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><a href=\"#_ftnref13\" name=\"_ftn13\">[13]<\/a> Darrell Posey, Intellectual Property Rights: And Just Compensation for Indigenous Knowledge, Anthropology Today, Vol6, No.4 (Aug., 1990), 13-16<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><a href=\"#_ftnref14\" name=\"_ftn14\">[14]<\/a> Stephen B. Brush, Indigenous Knowledge of Biological Resources and Intellectual Property Rights: The Role of Anthropology, <em>American Anthropologist, <\/em>New Series, Vol.95, No.3 (Sep., 1993), 653-671.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><a href=\"#_ftnref15\" name=\"_ftn15\">[15]<\/a> Madhav Gadgil; P.R.Seshagiri Rao; G.Utkarsh; P.Pramod; Ashwini Chhatre; Members of the People\u2019s Biodiversity Initiative, New Meanings for Old Knowledge: The People\u2019s Biodiversity Registers Program, <em>Ecological Applications, <\/em>Vol.10, No.4 (Oct., 2000), 1307-1317.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><a href=\"#_ftnref16\" name=\"_ftn16\">[16]<\/a> R.David Simpson; Roger A Sedjo and John W Reid, Valuing Biodiversity for Use in Pharmaceutical Research, <em>The Journal of Politicla Economy, <\/em>Vol.104, No.1 (Feb., 1996), 163-185.<\/p>\n<p style=\"text-align:justify;\"><a href=\"#_ftnref17\" name=\"_ftn17\">[17]<\/a> Patricia Longley Cochran, Ethical Guidelines for the Use of Traditional Knowledge in Research and Science <em>(Adapted from Traditional Knowledge Research <\/em>Guidelines<em>\u2014 Council of Yukon First Nations\u2014http:\/\/www.cyfn.ca\/index.html) Downloaded on 18<sup>th<\/sup> August 2005 from <\/em><a href=\"http:\/\/www.ed.psu.edu\/icik\/2004Proceedings\/section8-cochran.pdf\">http:\/\/www.ed.psu.edu\/icik\/2004Proceedings\/section8-cochran.pdf<\/a>.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Abstract There is a widespread concern all over the world about the emerging tensions in the local, regional and global dialogues on relationship between formal and informal knowledge systems. It [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[1],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-5464","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-uncategorized"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/demo.honeybee.org\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/5464","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/demo.honeybee.org\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/demo.honeybee.org\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/demo.honeybee.org\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/demo.honeybee.org\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcomments&post=5464"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/demo.honeybee.org\/index.php?rest_route=\/wp\/v2\/posts\/5464\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/demo.honeybee.org\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fmedia&parent=5464"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/demo.honeybee.org\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Fcategories&post=5464"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/demo.honeybee.org\/index.php?rest_route=%2Fwp%2Fv2%2Ftags&post=5464"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}